Etsy is often touted as the best place to sell vintage on, but eBay’s userbase continues to grow. The two platforms have a lot in common and offer different advantages for selling vintage goods online. So which site should you focus your efforts towards?

The “etsy vs ebay selling fees” is a question that has been asked many times. Etsy and eBay are two of the most popular websites for buying and selling vintage items. Which site should you use?

Selling Vintage on Etsy Vs eBay - The Best and Where to Start

Are you debating whether to sell vintage on Etsy or eBay and having trouble deciding? 

Maybe you’ve been wondering who prefers Etsy. Or perhaps it’s simpler to sell antique stuff on eBay? Another issue that may be bugging you is shipping expenses, which are a major source of frustration for any seller.

You may also be interested in learning how to promote and advertise on Etsy or eBay. Then I’m delighted you’ve stopped by. 

I’ll walk you through the differences between selling vintage on Etsy and eBay step by step and answer all of your burning questions. 

Here’s a table that compares Etsy with eBay for your convenience.

Features Etsy eBay
What are you able to sell here? Handmade things that are vintage, one-of-a-kind, and innovative. Almost everything, including automobiles and used goods.
Advantages of Selling Here Low seller fees are appealing to those who like antique things. Money-back guarantee on a reliable platform Feature of an auction There is no charge for listing.
The Drawbacks of Selling Here Policies are being updated all the time. Without your permission, you’ll be included to offsite adverts. The Auction function might lead to low-ball pricing due to the high amount of competition.
Base of Customers Items manufactured at home are preferred. I’m looking for a genuine experience. Customers in search of a good price on gadgets and used products
Selling Ease is a term used to describe how simple it is to sell something It takes some getting accustomed to, but Etsy features a lot of useful, easy-to-understand recommendations. It’s easier than Etsy, and it’s comparable to creating a Facebook page.
Fees for Shipping You can choose which country you want to ship to based on your Fees for Shipping If you offer free shipping to USA or Canada shoppers, you will rank higher The seller’s decision
Fees for Sellers Each product listing costs USD USD $0.20 for each product listing Transaction fee of 6.5% of the selling price for each item that you sold.20. For each item you sold, you will be charged a transaction fee of 6.5 percent of the selling amount. There is no charge for the first 250 items listed. After then, pay USD No listing fee for the first 250 listed items Then pay USD $0.35 for each listed item Transaction fee is a percentage of your sale plus USD $0.30.35 for each item on the list. A transaction charge is calculated as a percentage of your sale + No listing fee for the first 250 listed items Then pay USD $0.35 for each listed item Transaction fee is a percentage of your sale plus USD $0.30.30 USD.
Optional Plans Etsy Plus is a $10/month membership that will help you enhance your selling experience. USD $21.95 per month for the Basic Store USD $59.95 per month for Premium Store
Marketing and Advertising Paid advertisements are available both on-site and off-site. Use Promotions Manager to run adverts.
Tools for E-Commerce Has third-party tools to enhance the selling experience on Etsy Can simply sell on eBay eBay Favorites ListBay Wish List

Please take a seat as we learn all there is to know about:

  • What Is Etsy and How Does It Work?
  • The Benefits of Selling on Etsy
  • The Drawbacks of Selling on Etsy
  • What Is eBay and How Does It Work?
  • Advantages of Selling on eBay
  • The Drawbacks of Selling on eBay
  • What Does It Mean to Sell Vintage?
  • What Kinds of Things Can You Sell on Etsy?
  • What Kinds of Things Can You Sell On eBay?
  • Base of Customers of Etsy
  • Base of Customers of eBay
  • Selling Ease is a term used to describe how simple it is to sell something On Etsy
  • Selling Ease is a term used to describe how simple it is to sell something On eBay
  • Fees for Shipping Of Etsy
  • Fees for Shipping Of eBay
  • Fees for Sellers Of Etsy
  • Fees for Sellers Of eBay
  • Etsy and eBay do not allow you to sell certain items.
  • Optional Plans For Etsy
  • Optional Plans for eBay
  • Marketing and Advertising For Etsy
  • Marketing and Advertising For eBay
  • Tools for E-Commerce For Etsy
  • Tools for E-Commerce For eBay


Some of the links on this page are affiliate links, which means that if you click on them, I may get a commission at no additional cost to you. I hope you find the information provided here to be helpful! Thanks!

Etsy Related Articles:

What Is Etsy and How Does It Work?

Etsy is a global marketplace for antique, one-of-a-kind, and creative items. If you’re selling on Etsy, you’re undoubtedly already familiar with the essentials. 

It’s an online marketplace where vendors can list their antique or handmade items and customers may buy them for a set fee. 

Everything is set up for you, and all you have to do as the seller is complete a few steps to set up the design element and you’re good to begin. The best part is that anybody can sell on Etsy.

The Benefits of Selling on Etsy

Etsy is a fantastic platform for individuals to sell their antique items. The cheap costs, which may be as low as 6.5 percent per transaction and USD Etsy is a great place for people of all kinds to sell their vintage wares. Many new Etsy sellers are drawn in by the low fees, which can be as little as 6.5% per sale and USD $0.20 per listing..20 every listing, attract many new Etsy merchants. 

Etsy caters to a certain demographic. It’s not like Amazon or Lazada, where you can buy almost everything. Etsy’s specialty is antique, handcrafted, creative, and one-of-a-kind items. 

The Etsy community forum is quite supportive of one another, and members are typically happy to provide advice on the forum site. 

Finally, the biggest benefit of selling on Etsy is that there will be 81.9 million purchasers on the platform by 2020. As an Etsy seller, you have immediate access to this large market.

As a result, it attracts suppliers and customers who are interested in similar items.

The Drawbacks of Selling on Etsy

There are a few drawbacks to selling on Etsy. The first is that Etsy’s advertising regulations are continuously changing. Etsy advertises on Facebook and Instagram in addition to its website.

You may be featured in their offsite advertisements without your agreement, depending on your goods and how successfully you listed it.

You are not paid for views to your advertisements as a seller, but if sales are made via those ads, you will be charged a 15% or 10% advertising fee, based on your income over the previous 12 months. 

Another disadvantage is that the listing cost might eat into your money over time. This is due to the fact that you must pay a listing fee for each product you list, which is only valid for four months.

What Is eBay and How Does It Work?

Unlike Etsy, where you may purchase products at a set price, eBay allows you to bid on items. Shoppers may place bids on products that have been advertised, and the price may differ from what was initially stated.

The items offered on eBay are increasingly diverse, and they might even contain automobiles.

Advantages of Selling on eBay

The most significant benefit of selling on eBay is the degree of confidence that customers have in the marketplace. If consumers’ orders are not delivered, eBay offers a money-back guarantee. 

You may also auction items on eBay, which is a unique and entertaining component of selling on eBay. This provides a distinct experience for your customers and boosts their involvement.

There is no listing cost on eBay, however there is a sales transaction fee. This implies that merchants may continue to offer items without having to pay for them. 

Finally, if buyers want to window shop, they may look through hundreds of various things at once, but on Etsy, customers can only search for products by category. 

The Drawbacks of Selling on eBay

The quantity of competition on eBay is the primary issue for new eBay sellers. The earnings of eBay have been constantly rising. 

This indicates that sales are increasing. Because more individuals are selling antique items on eBay, it might be tough to stand out among all the other listings. 

Selling vintage on eBay may be just as profitable as selling vintage on Etsy if you are ready to put some effort into your listings (and accept a reduction in profit margins).

While the auction function might enhance customer involvement and keep things fresh, it can also be unpleasant. You may have to deal with consumers who attempt to undercut you on price on a regular basis.

What Does It Mean to Sell Vintage?

selling vintage on etsy vs ebay what does selling vintage mean

Anything that is at least 20 years old is considered vintage. Vintage may refer to any object manufactured before the year 2000, regardless of its age, on Etsy and eBay. 

When selling vintage, keep the term “antique” in mind. Your objects may be vintage, but if they are more than 100 years old, they will be called antiques.

Vintage does not always imply “used” on Etsy and eBay. 

Many folks will offer new-old-stock items; all you have to do is make sure they’re in excellent condition and designate them as such in your listings. 

Selling antique things on Etsy or eBay is a great way to meet other vintage collectors who are seeking for one-of-a-kind products. 

Additionally, some individuals are experimenting with antique things in order to be more environmentally conscious and to breathe new life into something old.

What Kinds of Things Can You Sell on Etsy?

Etsy is a fantastic platform for antique vendors. You may purchase or sell anything handmade, vintage, antique, or related materials. 

Etsy is not the place to offer mass-produced or store-bought items. You also cannot resell anything on Etsy, even if they are handmade. 

Furthermore, you are unable to sell services. This implies that if you provide virtual yoga courses or party planning services, Etsy is not the place to put them up for sale.

What Kinds of Things Can You Sell On eBay?

 eBay is a terrific place to sell used stuff! People are constantly looking for a good deal, and eBay is a great place to locate one.

Because of its bid feature, eBay is not recommended for mass-produced products. Electronics were the most popular item on eBay, which is a no-no on Etsy.

Base of Customers of Etsy

The Base of Customers of Etsy is about 81.9 million buyers. These people are mainly committed to buying handmade or vintage products from small business owners on Etsy.

Shoppers on Etsy enjoy authenticity and the ability to form direct relationships with their vendors.

Base of Customers of eBay

selling vintage on etsy vs ebay Base of Customers of ebay

The Base of Customers of eBay has about 181 million buyers. The eBay app is the third most downloaded app in the United States, coming behind Amazon and Walmart.

As electronics and second-hand goods are amongst the most popular items on eBay, its Base of Customers is mainly shoppers who are looking to get a good deal on these items.

Selling Ease is a term used to describe how simple it is to sell something On Etsy

Etsy is a little more complicated than eBay. It might be daunting and perplexing if you are unfamiliar with the platform. 

This is due to the fact that you must design your shop, include extensive product descriptions, do keyword analysis, and so on. There are, however, some wonderful resources available to assist you in figuring it out! 

The Etsy guide to starting a business is well-written and easy to follow.

To learn how to sell your antique items on Etsy, be prepared to do keyword research, study your rivals, and read all there is to know about Etsy.

All of work will be beneficial after you’ve created a lovely Etsy shop and sold your first item. 

Selling Ease is a term used to describe how simple it is to sell something On eBay

Selling on eBay is a lot faster and simpler than selling on Etsy. Consider it a Facebook page for your goods. You are not need to consider shop design or templates.

Simply establish an account, provide product information, and submit your listing, and you’re ready to go.

You may register now (or tomorrow – whichever works best for you!) and begin utilizing the platform right away. 

If you want to get started fast and simply and aren’t worried with converting your passion into a full-time profession, eBay is a superior place for selling your old items.

Related Articles

Fees for Shipping Of Etsy

You may pick where your shipment will come from on Etsy. It’s possible to set it up differently for purchasers from various nations. 

As a result, only consumers who can receive your items will see your Etsy listings.

For customers in the United States and Canada, Etsy offers free delivery. If you choose this option, your product will appear higher in search results than those that do not offer free delivery.

The fees, however, will be incurred by the seller, but you may consider of them as advertising expenditures since it boosts your item’s rating.

Fees for Shipping Of eBay

selling vintage on etsy vs ebay Fees for Shipping of ebay

eBay Fees for Shipping are The seller’s decision. You can use the shipping calculator on eBay to assess your costs.

For your convenience, eBay offers a helpful guide about UPS and USPS package kinds here.

When deciding between eBay and Etsy, keep in mind that your eBay items are exposed to everyone. 

Fees for Sellers Of Etsy

A listing fee of USD Sellers will have to pay a listing fee of USD $0.20 for each product listing, and it lasts for 4 months. The transaction fee is 6.5% of the selling price for every sale you make..20 will be charged for each product listing, which will be valid for four months. Every sale you make incurs a transaction charge of 6.5 percent of the selling price.

These might cut into your profit margins in small firms. As a result, you must be cautious in determining how much you may list and including it into your price.

Fees for Sellers Of eBay

For the first 250 goods listed on eBay, sellers will not be charged a listing fee. Following that, they must pay up to USD eBay sellers will not pay any listing fee for the first 250 items they list. After that, they need to pay up to USD $0.35 per product they list..35 for each product they list. 

The transaction costs on eBay are a little more complicated. They take a cut of a percentage of your selling price + eBay transaction fees are a bit more complex. They take a percentage of your sales price plus USD $0.30 per sale as a cut. However, the percentage taken varies according to the type of product sold..30 USD every sale. The proportion taken, however, varies according on the sort of commodity sold. 

In the discussion between Etsy and eBay fees, you’ll need to carefully assess your expenditures based on your requirements.

Etsy and eBay do not allow you to sell certain items.

Etsy and eBay have similar restrictions on what you may sell. 

  • Items that are harmful
  • Items that are illegal
  • Items that encourage violence
  • Weapons
  • components of the human body
  • Drugs
  • Animals
  • Pornographic Material

However, one significant distinction between selling on Etsy and eBay is that, although you may resell things on eBay, you cannot resell handcrafted items on Etsy. 

Optional Plans For Etsy

Etsy Plus provides merchants with Subscription Plans. Etsy + gives merchants extra tools to improve their selling experience.

It also provides vendors with personalized site hosting and a domain name to help them identify themselves. Finally, it provides extra discounts and promotional materials to vendors to aid in their public relations efforts. 

All of this for just $10 per month.

If you live in the United States, you may take advantage of Etsy installments. They only need to pick the Klarna option at the checkout counter, and they may pay in installments.

Optional Plans for eBay

eBay offers extensive Optional Plans for its sellers.

  • USD $21.95 per month for the Basic Store
  • USD $59.95 per month for Premium Store

It offers fixed-price listings for high-volume sellers, shipping discounts, and reduced Fees for Sellers.

Both of these choices are better for sellers who want to offer more than 1000 items.

In the subscription war between eBay and Etsy, it seems that Etsy is the more economical option. However, you must analyze your whole company demands, not just the eBay vs. Etsy expenses.

Marketing and Advertising For Etsy

If you have good product listings, do proper keyword research and take pretty photos, you have done most of the Marketing and Advertising for your product already.

You may lure shoppers by including a compelling rationale for being an Etsy seller or a lovely backstory on the origins of your goods.

If you still want more traffic, you may subscribe to Etsy Ads, which is limited at your daily maximum budget. 

This means Etsy will put your product listing at the top of the search results, and you will only be paid for clicks, not views, on your ad.

Etsy also runs offsite advertisements, which display your items on other platforms like Google, Facebook, Pinterest, and Instagram if they match search intent.

You will be paid only for completed orders, not for ad clicks or views. However, the advertising prices are a little more for this.

  • Sellers who have earned more than $10,000 in the last 12 months will be charged a 12 percent commission.
  • Sellers who have earned less than $10,000 in the last 12 months will be charged 15%.

As a result, for high-revenue vendors, offsite advertisements are marginally more lucrative. 

Marketing and Advertising For eBay

selling vintage on etsy vs ebay Marketing and Advertising for ebay

You may also use the Promotions Manager to promote your eBay store. It walks you through the process of setting up your eBay ads step by step.

Here are some things to think about before investing in eBay ads:

  • It will be difficult to be seen organically if you are offering a highly competitive product. As a result, adverts might assist you in standing out.
  • If you get a lot of favorable feedback, your adverts have a greater possibility of converting more purchases.
  • Other platforms have informed you that your product is excellent and high quality, but it isn’t receiving the attention it deserves. Advertisements may assist you in this area.

Tools for E-Commerce For Etsy

Sellers may offer their things for sale immediately on Etsy thanks to a built-in function. The built-in function on Etsy is advantageous since it may help you get greater visibility on the site and allows merchants to personalize their storefronts.  

Additionally, there are third-party Tools for E-Commerce that can help sellers take advantage of features that are not available on Etsy.

Third-party Tools for E-Commerce are better for sellers who are looking to sell through multiple channels, manage inventory across their different channels, and publish listings automatically. 

Etsy sellers might think about using the following third-party tools:

  • Outfy is a tool for Etsy sellers that is similar to Canva. Create content and automate your posts.
  • Referral Candy: This enables you to reward your consumers for referring your items to others.
  • Pick Fu: Survey your clients online to find out what they want.
  • Ecomdash: Easily manage your inventory across numerous platforms with the aid of Ecomdash.
  • All-in-one Etsy SEO Keyword Research Tool: Sales Samurai

Tools for E-Commerce For eBay

Tools for E-Commerce for ebay

eBay has a number of intriguing eCommerce capabilities, including:

  • eBay Wish List: You may create a wish list of things you’d want to purchase in the future and be alerted when they become available.
  • Favorites List: Make a list of products that you like. This information will be used by eBay to show you related goods.

Here are some third-party Tools for E-Commerce you can subscribe to enhance your experience as a seller:

  • With the vast variety of fees that you may be charged on eBay, this calculator is useful for calculating your profit margin while planning.
  • If you’re having trouble coming up with catchy names for your eBay listings, this is the tool for you.
  • To assist you automate your product listings using a spreadsheet, Codistor Channel Cloud is available.
  • Listing Analytics on eBay: This is a free feature for all sellers, but you must subscribe in order to use it. You’ll be able to evaluate how well your postings are doing and make any revisions.

As you can see, in the battle of Etsy vs eBay, the Tools for E-Commerce on both platforms are very useful.

What Makes Something Vintage?

Qualifying benefits of selling antique on Etsy compared. eBay: Vintage things on Etsy must be at least 20 years old. “Old-inspired” objects, on the other hand, are modern pieces that reflect the same style and spirit as vintage designs.

Be prepared for Etsy to ask for proof of antique signs in the form of photos. Furthermore, do not attempt to sell antique garments that have never been sold and label them as vintage.

Because they allow consumers to possess a piece of history, vintage things often sell for more than “vintage-inspired” items. 

“Antique-inspired” things, on the other hand, are more cheap for purchasers searching for something that was inspired by vintage styles but does not have as much historical relevance.

Another thing to think about is if you’re selling art on Etsy or eBay. If a piece of art is more than 20 years old, it is considered vintage.

can i sell vintage jewelry on ebay

Vintage jewelry on Etsy vs. eBay: You may sell vintage jewelry on Etsy. Etsy features a section on their website dedicated to antique jewelry listings. 

Your jewelry cannot be resold if it was crafted by hand. Vintage jewelry is incredibly popular on Etsy, and costs vary greatly based on how it is constructed, the picture quality, and the products utilized.

Is Etsy Exclusively For Vintage Items?

is etsy meant for vintage products

Downsides of selling antique on Etsy vs. eBay: Etsy isn’t only for vintage items. You may also sell fresh hand-made or hand-crafted things. 

The most crucial thing is that the things you sell on Etsy are legal and do not violate their laws.

Is Reselling Items On Etsy Illegal?

is it illegal to resell items on etsy

When it comes to selling vintage on Etsy compared. eBay, there are a few things to keep in mind: Etsy’s regulations on this are extremely clear. You are not permitted to resale things that are labeled as handcrafted. This is due to the fact that you did not create them.

Vintage artifacts and craft materials are the only things that may be resold. Please do not contemplate repackaging handmade things in order to give them a handmade feel in order to resell them.

Etsy will remove it, and it will have an impact on your future search rankings.

Etsy vs eBay: Which Is Better For Sellers?

You must be asking, Etsy or eBay, now that you know all the benefits of selling vintage on Etsy versus eBay.

If you’re just getting started in company and want to keep prices low, eBay is a good place to start.

This is because you may list up to 250 goods for free. That way, you may experiment and play around to see which goods are more popular.

Another good incentive to start with eBay is the ease of usage. It’s a lot less complicated than Etsy. 

You may try Etsy if you’ve gained some confidence or have some additional cash and time to spare.

The inexpensive start-up expenses of both platforms are appealing when compared to conventional brick-and-mortar retailers. Even so, you should weigh the costs of Etsy vs. eBay before making a decision.

If you’re debating whether to sell vintage on eBay or Etsy, Etsy is a good place to start because of the niche market that loves these products.

eBay is the place to go if your items are mostly electronics or gadgets.


That’s all there is to it, guys! This is the most comprehensive guide on selling vintage on Etsy vs. eBay that you will find.

I hope this post was helpful in determining whether you should sell on Etsy or eBay.

Good luck with any decision you choose, and I hope you make a lot of money!

Selling Vintage on Etsy vs. eBay: Which is Better and Where Should You Begin?

Etsy is a social marketplace for buying and selling handmade goods. It was founded in 2005, and has grown to be the largest online market place for handmade goods in the world. With over 32 million active sellers on Etsy, it’s easy to see why it’s so popular. However, if you’re looking for something more traditional like eBay, there are many benefits of using this site as well. Reference: etsy vs ebay for buyers.

  • etsy vs ebay 2021
  • ebay vs etsy vs mercari
  • ebay vs etsy reddit
  • etsy vs ebay vs shopify
  • etsy or ebay for selling jewelry
You May Also Like

50 Powerful Financial Affirmations for Manifesting Money!

There’s no question that money can be a touchy subject. How we…

How to survive (& thrive) if you’re cash poor in retirement

The average retiree has $88,000 in their account. This is not enough…

What to Do If You Can’t Pay Your Bills

Paying the bills is a time-consuming and often stressful task. There can…

8 Best Jobs That Pay for College

The cost of a college education has increased at an alarming rate…